Losing Employer Coverage

An open cardboard moving box. Photo: Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0.

A minimalist meeting room — Minimalist meeting room. Photo: Wikimedia Commons, CC0.

Exhibition stands in a hall — Exhibition stands at MESAP 2019. Photo: Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0.

Losing a job is disruptive enough without losing health coverage at the same time. The good news is that losing job-based coverage is one of the clearest qualifying life events in the system: it opens a special enrollment period on the Marketplace, and it opens a COBRA election window for staying on your old plan. The bad news is that both windows are 60 days, they overlap, and the choice you make inside them is hard to undo. This guide walks through the steps in order.

The timeline, in one paragraph

Your special enrollment period generally runs from 60 days before your coverage ends to 60 days after it ends, so you can line up a new plan before the old one stops. Your COBRA election period is at least 60 days from the date you receive the COBRA election notice. Coverage you pick through special enrollment generally starts on the first day of the month after you pick a plan. COBRA, if you elect it, is generally retroactive to the day your old coverage ended, so there is no gap if you elect it in time.

Step 1: Find out exactly when your coverage ends

Coverage does not always end on your last day of work. Some employers end coverage at the end of the month, some on the last day, and some continue it through a severance period. Your separation letter, benefits portal, or human resources department should state the date, and that date, not your last working day, starts the clock. If you cannot get a date in writing, ask for it, because every later deadline is measured from it, and a wrong assumption here can cost you the window.

Step 2: Gather the documents you will need

The Marketplace will usually ask for proof that you lost coverage: a letter from your employer or insurer showing the coverage end date, a COBRA election notice, or a similar document. You generally have 30 days after picking a plan to provide it. Gather it before you apply, not after, and keep a copy. If your employer is slow, apply anyway within the window and provide the document when it arrives, rather than waiting and missing the window altogether.

Step 3: Compare the three real options

Marketplace plan. Usually the cheapest option if you qualify for a premium tax credit, and the only subsidized option. Your doctors and drugs may change, and your deductible resets, so check the network and drug list first.

COBRA. You keep the exact same plan, doctors, and deductible progress, but you pay the full premium, employer and employee shares together, plus up to 2% for administration, with no subsidy. COBRA generally lasts up to 18 months after a job loss, and longer in some circumstances. It is best as a bridge when you are mid-treatment, when your deductible is already met for the year, or when you expect new job-based coverage soon.

A spouse's or parent's plan. Losing your coverage is a qualifying event for joining a spouse's job-based plan, and aging off a parent's plan at 26 is a qualifying event for the Marketplace. Compare the dependent premium and the network before assuming this is the cheap option: dependent premiums on a spouse's plan can be high, and the plan's affordability test for subsidies is a separate question.

Step 4: Decide inside the window, and understand the trap

Electing COBRA does not cancel your Marketplace window, as long as you switch within the same 60 days. But after that window closes, voluntarily dropping COBRA, or stopping payments, does not open a new special enrollment period. You would be stuck on COBRA until it runs out or until the next open enrollment, unless you have another qualifying event. That is the trap, and it catches people who elect COBRA as a holding position and then find they cannot afford it three months later. If COBRA is unaffordable month after month, a Marketplace plan inside the window is usually the safer choice, even if it means a new network and a new deductible.

Step 5: Enroll, confirm, and report changes

Enroll through HealthCare.gov or your state marketplace, pay the first premium on time, because coverage generally does not start until it is paid, and keep the confirmation, the plan documents, and the proof of loss together. If your income changes during the year, report it, because your advance credit is based on your estimate. If you get a new job with coverage, report that too, and do not pay for two plans longer than you need to. If you exhaust COBRA later, that exhaustion is itself a loss of coverage that opens a new special enrollment period.

Do not let the window close while you research. Sixty days passes quickly when you are job hunting, and there is no late exception for having been busy. Apply in the first weeks, even if you are still comparing plans, because an application can be updated and a plan can be changed inside the window, but a missed window generally cannot be reopened.

Sources: HealthCare.gov, losing job-based coverage and special enrollment pages; U.S. Department of Labor, COBRA continuation coverage guidance; 45 CFR section 155.420 (special enrollment periods).

General information only. This page explains the U.S. health insurance Marketplace in plain English. It is not insurance, medical, tax, or legal advice, and it cannot tell you which plan to buy or what you will pay. Your price depends on your age, household, income, location, and the plans in your area. Always confirm the current rules, dates, and your own price on HealthCare.gov or your state marketplace before you act. Contact: hello [at] tapetoolhq.com.